The Church and the Petrine Primacy

Mar Ivanios’ ecclesial vision was deeply shaped by his theological reflections on the role of the Petrine primacy in the life of the Church. He saw the Papacy not as a mere administrative or centralizing authority but as a ministry of communion, service, and fidelity to the apostolic faith. For Mar Ivanios, the Papacy symbolized the visible center of unity within the universal Church and served as the guardian of doctrinal integrity. His acceptance of the Petrine office was rooted in his belief that communion with Rome was essential for the unity and apostolic authenticity of the Church.

Peter as the Rock of Unity
Mar Ivanios grounded his understanding of the Papacy in Scripture, particularly in Christ’s words to Peter:

“You are Peter, and on this rock I will build my Church, and the gates of Hades will not prevail against it” (Matthew 16:18).

He interpreted this passage as Christ’s commission to Peter to serve as the foundational figure of unity in the Church. For Mar Ivanios, the Petrine office was not about dominance or centralization but about ensuring that the Church remained one in faith and communion¹.

A Ministry of Service
Drawing from the Eastern Christian tradition, Mar Ivanios viewed the Papacy as a ministry of service to the universal Church. He emphasized that Peter’s role as the “first among equals” was intended to strengthen his brethren (Luke 22:32) and to guide the Church in fidelity to Christ’s teachings. Mar Ivanios frequently highlighted the humility and sacrificial nature of Peter’s leadership, which he believed was exemplified in the Papacy. He wrote:

“The See of Peter must be a ministry of love and service, not of control; its purpose is to unify, not to divide.”²

The Papacy as the Visible Center of Unity
Mar Ivanios was deeply troubled by the divisions within the Malankara Church and the broader Christian community. He saw the Papacy as the God-given means to restore and maintain unity among the diverse traditions of the Church. He reflected:

“The Church is one Body, but it has many members. The Petrine office ensures that these members remain united in Christ, without losing their distinct identities.”³

For Mar Ivanios, the Papacy was not a centralizing force that suppressed local traditions but a unifying presence that safeguarded the diversity of the Church.

Unity in Diversity
Mar Ivanios’ vision of the Church was characterized by the principle of unity in diversity. He believed that communion with the See of Rome allowed the Malankara Church to retain its distinct liturgical, spiritual, and theological traditions while participating in the universal mission of the Catholic Church. His acceptance of the Papacy was not a rejection of the Malankara Church’s autonomy but an affirmation of its place within the larger Catholic communion.

Theological Balance: Universal and Local Dimensions
Mar Ivanios had a profound understanding of the interplay between the universal Church and the local Churches. He believed that the Church was both a communion of local Churches and the Body of Christ united under the Petrine ministry. He maintained that the authority of the Pope did not negate the legitimate autonomy of local Churches. Instead, it ensured that local Churches remained rooted in the apostolic faith and in communion with the universal Church.

Mar Ivanios argued:

“The universal Church and the local Church are not in opposition but are two dimensions of the same reality. The Papacy is the link that binds these dimensions together.”⁴

Malankara Church as a Model
Through his efforts to bring the Malankara Church into communion with Rome, Mar Ivanios demonstrated how a local Church could retain its autonomy while fully participating in the universality of the Catholic Church. His insistence on preserving the liturgical, spiritual, and administrative traditions of the Malankara Church became a model for how other Eastern Churches could enter into communion with Rome without losing their distinctiveness⁵.

Guardian of Orthodoxy
Mar Ivanios saw the Papacy as the guardian of doctrinal integrity in the Church. He believed that the Pope’s role was to preserve the apostolic faith handed down through the centuries and to ensure that all Churches remained faithful to the teachings of Christ and the apostles.

“The See of Peter is a lighthouse guiding the Church through the storms of history, keeping it anchored to the truth of the Gospel,” Mar Ivanios wrote⁶.

Theological Reflections on the Papal Office
Mar Ivanios’ theological reflections on the Papacy were shaped by his studies of Church history and canon law. He admired the early ecumenical councils, where the Bishop of Rome played a pivotal role in resolving doctrinal disputes while respecting the autonomy of the Eastern Churches. His acceptance of the Petrine primacy was thus both theological and historical, rooted in his conviction that the Papacy was essential for the unity and mission of the Church.

A Theological Act of Communion
Mar Ivanios’ historic reunion with Rome in 1930 was not merely an administrative decision but a profound theological act. He saw it as a restoration of the Malankara Church’s full communion with the universal Church, centered on the See of Peter. His profession of faith before the Apostolic Delegate in Kandy included an affirmation of the Pope’s primacy and his commitment to the unity of the Church. For Mar Ivanios, this act was a fulfillment of the Malankara Church’s apostolic vocation⁷.

A Model for Other Churches
The reunion of the Malankara Church with Rome under Mar Ivanios’ leadership became a model for other Eastern Churches seeking communion with the Catholic Church. It demonstrated that full communion with the Papacy could be achieved without compromising the unique identity and autonomy of local Churches.

Contribution to Catholic Ecclesiology
Mar Ivanios’ theological reflections on the Papacy have enriched Catholic ecclesiology. His emphasis on the Papacy as a ministry of communion, rather than domination, continues to inform the Catholic Church’s dialogue with Eastern and Orthodox Churches.

A Witness to Unity
Mar Ivanios’ life and work stand as a powerful witness to the importance of the Papacy in the Church’s mission of unity. His acceptance of the Petrine primacy, while preserving the Malankara Church’s traditions, offers a path forward for ecumenical dialogue and reconciliation.

A Vision for the Future
Mar Ivanios’ vision of the Papacy as a ministry of service, humility, and unity remains relevant in a world where divisions within Christianity persist. His life demonstrates that the Papacy is not a stumbling block to unity but a bridge that connects the Church’s diverse traditions in communion with Christ.

1. Matthew 16:18, Holy Bible, New Testament.
2. Mar Ivanios, Letters on Church Unity, Bethany Archives, 1930.
3. Cyril Malancharuvil, The Syro-Malankara Church: Its Past and Present, Malankara Library, 2002.
4. Antony Valiyavilayil OIC, The Ecclesial Vision of Mar Ivanios, Bethany Publications, 2015.
5. Placid Podipara, The St. Thomas Christians, 1950.
6. Bar Sleeba OIC, The Missionary Zeal of Mar Ivanios, Bethany Publications, 1978.
7. Vatican Archives, Documents on the Reunion of the Malankara Church with Rome, 1930.

Previous | Next